Opened 8 months ago

Closed 3 months ago

#2131 closed defect (fixed)

Boundary thorn

Reported by: miguel.zilhao.nogueira@… Owned by:
Priority: major Milestone:
Component: EinsteinToolkit thorn Version: development version
Keywords: Boundary Cc:

Description (last modified by Roland Haas)

i was trying to do a (unigrid) run with "scalar" boundary conditions on some variables but with uneven boundary width, ie width of 2 grid points on the x and y axis and 0 on the z axis. in the documentation of the Boundary thorn it states that one should create a table passing this information in an array called "BOUNDARY_WIDTH":

"The table handle identifies a table which holds extra arguments for the particular boundary condition that is requested. For example, if a negative value is passed for the boundary width, then the boundary condition will look in this table for a 2d-element integer array, which holds the width of each face of the boundary (for a d dimensional grid variable). (The first element of the array holds the width of the ‘-x’ face, the second the ‘+x’ face, the third the ‘-y’ face, etc.)"

so i've accordingly created the following table

  call Util_TableCreateFromString(param_table_handle, "BOUNDARY_WIDTH = { 2 2 2 2 0 0 }")

and then registered the variables with

   ierr = Boundary_SelectGroupForBC(cctkGH, CCTK_ALL_FACES, -one,         &
        param_table_handle, "ScalarBase::phi", "scalar")

however, i was getting errors like the following:

  Boundary/src/Check.c:130: BndSanityCheckWidths: Assertion `dim < (int)sizeof(dims)' failed.

inspecting that file, this is only triggered if (boundary_widths[i] > 100 || boundary_widths[i] < 0) which meant that my BOUNDARY_WIDTH array was likely not being parsed correctly. digging a little bit deeper, i've found the following in ScalarBoundary.c:138 (and analogous for the other files under CactusBase/Boundary/src):

     /* Determine boundary width on all faces */
     /* allocate memory for buffer */
     gdim = CCTK_GroupDimI(gi);
     if (gdim > max_gdim) {
       width_alldirs =
           (CCTK_INT *)realloc(width_alldirs, 2 * gdim * sizeof(CCTK_INT));
       max_gdim = gdim;

     /* fill it with values, either from table or the boundary_width
        parameter */
     if (widths[i] < 0) {
       err = Util_TableGetIntArray(tables[i], gdim, width_alldirs,

it seems to me that this last line should be instead

       err = Util_TableGetIntArray(tables[i], 2 * gdim, width_alldirs,

for consistency with the rest of the file and with the documentation, right? indeed, with this change the errors disappeared. i've attached a simple patch that applies this on this file, but i guess an equivalent change would be needed also for the rest of the Boundary files...

if this patch is correct, could this be ported to the current release? and if it's not correct, is there anything i'm missing, in order to register the boundary conditions?

Attachments (2)

ScalarBoundary.patch (657 bytes) - added by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@… 8 months ago.
boundary.patch (3.8 KB) - added by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@… 3 months ago.

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (12)

Changed 8 months ago by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@…

Attachment: ScalarBoundary.patch added

comment:1 Changed 8 months ago by Erik Schnetter

Yes, this looks like an error in the code.

We will also need to have a look at the other files in the same directory,
as they might contain the same error.

comment:2 Changed 8 months ago by Roland Haas

Description: modified (diff)

comment:3 Changed 8 months ago by Roland Haas

Status: newconfirmed

comment:4 Changed 3 months ago by Roland Haas

Miguel, Erik: is there any progress on this?

comment:5 Changed 3 months ago by Roland Haas

Miguel, Erik: since you have already proposed a solution, would you like to propose a patch so that it could potentially be included in the next release?

Changed 3 months ago by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@…

Attachment: boundary.patch added

comment:6 Changed 3 months ago by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@…

There was already one patch proposed, but it only fixed one file. I've just added another patch, fixing all the files affected.

comment:7 Changed 3 months ago by Roland Haas

Status: confirmedreview

comment:8 Changed 3 months ago by Roland Haas

Status: reviewreviewed_ok

The patch looks fine to me.

Please apply.

Or let me know if you do not have commit rights and I will apply the patch with you as the author.

comment:9 Changed 3 months ago by miguel.zilhao.nogueira@…

I do not have commit rights... Could you take care of it?

comment:10 Changed 3 months ago by Roland Haas

Resolution: fixed
Status: reviewed_okclosed

Applied as git hash 08315df "Boundary: correct size of width_alldirs data array" of cactusbase.

Thank you.

I did not mention this, but one could have also created a pull request on bitbucket which anyone of the developers could then merge in (ideally using the fast-forward merge method to avoid having one additional merge commit for every pull requested commit).

Modify Ticket

Change Properties
Set your email in Preferences
as closed The ticket will remain with no owner.
The resolution will be deleted.

Add Comment

E-mail address and name can be saved in the Preferences.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.